Anyone who experiences dry, red, itchy eyes — either from seasonal allergies or chronic eye conditions — knows the pain associated with day to day living. Often a good eyelid scrub is the only thing that can provide the immediate relief needed in these types of situations. 

While it is essential to go to your eye doctor if you think your eyes have a severe infection, over-the-counter eyelid cleaning products can usually get the job done. Unfortunately, there are a lot of products out there. How do you know which ones are sensitive enough for your delicate eyes?

Luckily, we got you covered. In this article, we give you our top recommendations for the best eyelid scrubs on the market right now. We also give you a helpful buyer’s guide in case you never purchased eyelid scrubs and do not know anything about them. But first, let us look at how we rank the products.

Comparison Table

How We Choose the Eyelid Scrubs on This List

close up yellow eye

Photo by Skitterphoto from Pexels

To remain objective during the ranking process, we apply the same criteria to each product, so you know for sure what the best eyelid scrubs are. We start this product by selecting the top-selling eyelid scrub products. We then take a look at three distinct areas for each product. 

Specifically, we look at the ingredients, effectiveness and overall price. For each of these areas, we ask a series of questions that help us determine the strengths and weaknesses associated with each product. Once we get a good sense of the product, we assign it a score out of five stars. 

Here are some of the questions we ask during the ranking process:

  • Ingredients — What does the company use when making the product? Do any of the elements cause skin irritation? Are any of the parts all natural, or are they synthetic?
  • Effectiveness — Is the eyelid scrub effective at cleaning eyelids? Can it remove makeup easily? Does the product scratch your face easily?
  • Overall Price — How much does the eyelid scrub cost? How does the company justify charging this amount? Does the product represent a good value for the consumer?

Our Selections for the Top Six Best Eyelid Scrubs

1

If went based our score off user rating alone, then OCuSOFT Lid Scrub Plus would undoubtedly be the winner of the list. However, we believe that the reviews do the product justice. The product relieves eye irritation without causing a burning sensation — a rare find for medicated eye products.

We recommend OCuSOFT Lid Scrub Plus especially for people who suffer from specific eye conditions like chronic dry eye, chalazion, and blepharitis. We find that these eye drop pad help ease the pain associated with these conditions, like painful sores and itchy red eyes.

Often people suffering from a painful chalazion must undergo surgery to get it removed — especially if it grew large and infected. However, some individuals reported that using these wipes helped the chalazion go away on its own. While we cannot guarantee these results, we do think it is worth a shot. 

Not to mention the quality of the deal. Why quite a few prescriptions or significant strength over the counter medications cost upwards of forty dollars, thirty of these pads only costs around eighteen dollars. Considering the power with which they work, we think this deal is worth a try for anyone suffering. 

The only complaint we found associated with the product is that the wipes included are not big enough. While it is true that the wipes are not as big as some of the others on this list, we found that there typically is more than enough included for cleaning the eyes. Some people cut there’s in half to save.

2

Dr. Fischer Premium, Purified, Non-Irritating & Hypoallergenic Eyelid...
  • PREMIUM EYE CARE Wipes by Dr. Fischer bring you the gentlest and most effective eyelid wipes that are absolutely free of...
  • CLEANING YOUR EYELIDS & LASHES to get rid of oil, dirt, dust, crusted matter, ocular secretions and other foreign bodies...
  • CONJUNCTIVITIS and BLEPHARITIS (along with red eye, dry eye, eye inflammations, & styes) relief means that easing eye...

While the Dr. Fischer Premium, Purified, Non-Irritating & Hypoallergenic Eyelid Wipes might not be quite as effective as the OCuSOFT Lid Scrub Plus, Pre-Moistened Pads at treating and relieving chronic conditions; they are quite effective at cleaning the eyelids for everyday general use. 

They are also the cheapest product on this list since they cost only thirteen dollars. As such, we recommend them for people who want an excellent makeup remover or a way to remove any hardened eye fluid or dirt buildup in the eyes during a night of sleep.  

They also work well at combating the symptoms of allergies. However, the material that Dr. Fischer Premium uses is not very soft. While this is not a problem for everyday cleaning use, it very well could irritate certain eye conditions like styles. 

3

TheraTears Sterilid Eyelid Cleanser, Lid Scrub for Eyes and Eyelashes,...
  • TheraTears SteriLid Eyelid Cleanser removes oil, debris and other contaminants that can build up on the eyelids and...
  • Natural, plant-based formula with Tea Tree Oil
  • Regimen only takes 60 seconds

If you want a product that uses natural ingredients instead of manufactured ones, then you should go with the TheraTears Sterilid Eyelid Cleanser. The product uses all natural tea tree oil for fighting any dirt, bacteria or infections around your eyes. 

The product also works well for people who do not like wipe pads typically used by companies. The cleanser uses a cream which you can gently rub, around the eyelids. A forty-eight military container of TheraTears Sterilid Eyelid Cleanser costs around fifteen dollars. 

However, we should note that just because a product uses natural ingredients does not necessarily make it better than a more processed version. Indeed, in some cases, the manufactured parts can work better at fighting severe infections. 

4

If you want the very best money can buy, then the Eye Scrub Sterile Makeup Remover and Eyelid Cleansing Pads were made for you. We cannot deny that the material the pads use in undeniably soft  — nor the fact that they work great at combating severe eye infections and conditions. 

This reason is likely why many doctors recommend that their patients use this brand. Unfortunately, they come with one major drawback: the price. A thirty pad pack of Eye Scrub Sterile Makeup Remover and Eyelid Cleansing Pads cost around thirty-nine dollars — that is over a dollar per pad!

If the price is no object and you want the best product possible for combating your condition, then you should go with Eye Scrub Sterile Makeup Remover and Eyelid Cleansing Pads. But, we believe the price does not justify what you receive from the company. As such, we recommend going with a different brand. 

5

Clear C Premium No Rinse Non Irritating Eyelid Wipes 30 count -...
  • Soothing relief for irritated eyes
  • Cleans away oil and pollutants
  • Gentle rinse-free formula

At twenty dollars for a thirty count, Clear C Premium No Rinse Non-Irritating Eyelid Wipes represents a pretty good midrange value. And it seems that the product works for many different types of users, whether they have allergies or eye conditions.

However, there are some issues with the product that you should know about before you decide you want the product. The biggest complaint associated with the wipes is that they are too small, rough and, in some cases, dry. Some people also complained that the product irritated their eye and they needed to rinse it afterward. 

Considering the brand says ‘No Rinse’ in its title, we believe it should stand by this claim. We also do not see why people should pay more for a product that is not as good as some of the cheaper wipes on this list. 

6

Tea Tree Oil Face Soap and Eyelid Scrub for Support of Eyelid...
  • SUPPORT FOR SKIN BLEMISHES, IRRITATED EYES, AND ITCHY, INFLAMED SKIN CONDITIONS - Tea Tree oil removes contaminants and...
  • ORGANIC, 100% VEGAN, 100% ALL-NATURAL SUPPORT FOR YOUR SKIN - Organic green tea, Organic olive oil, Organic coconut oil,...
  • EASY TO USE - Wet your face and hands with lukewarm water. Lather soap in hands. Massage lather onto skin and onto...

The Heyedrate Tea Tree Oil Face Soap and Eyelid Scrub is another all natural alternative to the manufactured medicinal products Instead of chemicals on pads; the company uses a soap bar made out of tea tree oil, shea butter, coconut oil, olive oil, and green tea. 

One five-ounce bar of the Heyedrate Tea Tree Oil Face Soap and Eyelid Scrub costs around eighteen dollars. If you are vegan and looking for a product that contains no animal by-products or testing, then we think you will love all the organic products in this product. Plus, since all the ingredients include natural antimicrobial properties, it works well at fighting off severe infections from the eyelids. 

While the product works well at cleaning the eyelids in a natural way, it does come with one major flaw. If you get even a little bit of the product in your eyes, then it will sting them intensely. 

While it is easy to get around this issue by being careful sometimes accidents happen and when they do they can significantly worsen the condition of the eye. As such, we advise caution for anyone considering the product. It does represent a pretty good value, but it can backfire easily. 

Eyelid Scrub Frequently Asked Questions

If you never used an eyelid scrub, then you might have a lot of questions about these types of products. Luckily, in this section, we go over some common inquiries people have when it comes to related eye conditions and over-the-counter medications. 

What Are the Different Types of Eyelid Scrubs?

Why Would I Need to Use an Eyelid Scrub?

When Should I Use an Eyelid Scrub and When Should I Go to the Doctor?

Featured Image via Pexels

Pin It on Pinterest